Table 1

Number of reflective words by category and feedback type (Pilot 1—Fall 2004; five of nine students)

 

Future improvements

Critiques

Conceptual statements

Shouldas

Total (10 reflections)

Avg

 

Peer-generated feedback (w/checklist or coding sheet)

 

 

176

(52.1%)

 

 

70

(20.7%)

 

 

49

(14.5%) 

 

 

43

(12.7%)

 

 

338

 

 

33.8 

 

Visual record only

 

305

(71.6%) 

 

73

(17.1%)

 

33

(7.7%)

 

15

(3.5%)

 

426

 

42.6